Recommendation - College of Policing, September 2026
IOPC reference
Recommendations
The IOPC recommends that the College of Policing review and, where appropriate, update the domestic abuse APP on risks and vulnerabilities and associated DARA learning materials to strengthen guidance for officers on communicating risk to victims in domestic abuse cases. This should make clear that officers should use professional judgment when discussing the outcome of the risk assessment with the victim.
Officers should also clearly explain the nature and significance of identified risks and ensure communication is accurate, consistent and supports a victim's understanding and informed decision making about safety and safeguarding options. This should include examples of good practice for safeguarding medium-risk victims in the community, such as the structured neighbourhood policing follow-up approach identified by Dyfed-Powys.
This recommendation has arisen as a result of an independent investigation in which a victim was not informed that her situation involved high-risk elements of domestic abuse. Although national guidance, frameworks and training support risk communication and victim-centred safeguarding, the investigation found these were not consistently reflected in practice.
In this case, risk was not clearly communicated to the victim which is believed to have impacted her understanding of high risk elements and her decision making. This recommendation is intended to address gaps in guidance and application. It ensures officers have clear direction to support decisions about sharing risk information with victims. It also requires officers to explain what that risk means for victim safety and available safeguarding options.
In addition, it highlights examples of good practice for safeguarding medium-risk victims in the community, such as the structured neighbourhood policing follow-up approach identified by Dyfed-Powys. This may help reduce escalation or repeat harm.
Failing to communicate high-risk factors clearly can leave victims unaware of the seriousness of their situation. It can reduce their ability to take protective action and hinder informed choices about safeguarding. Information about risk should therefore be communicated to victims in a timely, appropriate and consistent manner with sufficient clarity to enable them to understand the nature and significance of the risks identified.
Not accepted
The College supports the underlying intention of this recommendation, namely that victims should be provided with clear and meaningful information about risk to support informed decision making regarding their safety and safeguarding options.
Having reviewed the recommendation against existing authorised professional practice (APP) and associated learning products, it is not immediately clear that there is a substantive gap within current national guidance. Existing Domestic Abuse APP already emphasises the importance of sharing risk assessment information with victims and their supporters and highlights the need to increase victims' understanding of the nature of the risks they face. In particular, the APP guidance on Risks and Vulnerabilities (please see: Risks and vulnerabilities | College of Policing). Here is states that risk assessment should be shared with victims and, where appropriate, their supporters.
Similarly, the APP guidance on Safeguarding (Safeguarding | College of Policing) promotes safety planning undertaken in consultation with the victim, recognising the importance of victim-centred decision making.
The investigation itself notes that national guidance, frameworks and training already support risk communication and victim-centred safeguarding, but that these principles were not consistently reflected in practice. This may suggest a gap between policy and operational application rather than a deficiency in the current APP framework.
The College would also be cautious about framing guidance in a way that encourages officers to communicate a risk assessment outcome as a definitive statement of risk. While it is important that victims understand the nature and significance of identified risk factors, this should be balanced against the need to exercise professional judgement and maintain a victim-centred approach. Effective communication with victims should focus on identified risks, their implications, and available safeguarding options, rather than reliance on risk gradings alone.
In relation to learning products, the Domestic Abuse Risk Assessment (DARA) training is principally focused on the process of risk identification and assessment. Its primary focus is the identification and assessment of risk rather than wider safeguarding activity, safety planning or longer-term risk management.
To further strengthen frontline capability in this area, the College has recently developed the First Line Public Protection Programme, aimed at first line responders attending incidents involving vulnerability and safeguarding concerns. The programme includes dedicated learning on risk and vulnerability and promotes a victim-centred approach to risk assessment, risk management and safeguarding. Whilst it does not specifically focus on communicating risk assessment outcomes to victims, it reinforces the importance of understanding victim circumstances, recognising risk factors and supporting informed safeguarding decision making. The course has been piloted within policing and is currently undergoing evaluation ahead of any national rollout, demonstrating the College's ongoing commitment to strengthening knowledge and practice in relation to risk and vulnerability.
With regard to the suggested inclusion of the Dyfed-Powys neighbourhood policing follow-up model as an example of good practice, the College would wish to understand the extent to which this approach has been subject to robust evaluation before considering its inclusion within national guidance or training products. Any practice highlighted within APP should normally be supported by an appropriate evidence base and a clear understanding of transferability across forces.
On this basis, the College considers that existing Domestic Abuse APP already provides officers with guidance on communicating risk, involving victims in safety planning, and managing risk on an ongoing basis. The recommendation appears to align with principles already contained within the APP, particularly within the Risks and Vulnerabilities (Risks and vulnerabilities | College of Policing) Safeguarding (Safeguarding | College of Policing) and Suspect Strategy (Suspect strategy | College of Policing) sections.